News Network Logo

Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has been accused of "making a mockery" of women's sport after suggesting that there could be some circumstances in which trans athletes could compete in women's sport.

Speaking to The House magazine, Nandy claimed that individual sports "should decide whether or not biological males should compete against women".

She added: "We ought to respect the fact that they're far more expert in making those judgments and decisions than we are.

"I want to make sure that they feel supported, to be able to make those decisions fairly, but I think most have come to the conclusion now, although they want to be as inclusive as possible, biology does matter when it comes to sport."

Hitting out at Nandy's remarks, former Olympic athlete Mara Yamauchi slammed the Labour politician for contributing to the "corruption of women's sport" by "leaving it to national bodies" to decide.

Speaking on GB News, Yamauchi explained: "She said biology does matter - she's correct, that's the truth, I welcome that. But the logical next step of 'biology does matter' is that males should not be competing in the female category under any circumstances.

"Sport needs to be fair and safe for women and girls. But what she said instead was, let's leave this to our national governing bodies to decide - in theory that would be okay, but in practice it has proved not to be."

Host Patrick Christys suggested that it appears Nandy is "passing the buck" on trans issues in sport, and put the argument to Discrimination Lawyer Robin Moira White as to whether biology "does matter in women's sport".

In defence of Nandy and British sport, White argued that many of the trans issues within female sports are "happening in America", and governing bodies such as British Cycling have "followed the science and followed the law".

LATEST DEVELOPMENTS:

NHS given new guidelines for how to treat trans patients with 'safety and dignity'Elon Musk declares his trans child is 'dead' after being killed by 'woke virus'Hedman demands 'compromise' from darts chiefs and makes feelings clear on trans athletes

White told GB News: "If we actually look at British Cycling, they are one of those codes that Mara would support. There are other sporting codes where the sport is not gender affected, such as shooting.

"On the other hand, we've just watched Wimbledon where the strength of serve is important, and it would be very obvious that the strength of serve would make a difference in terms of fair competition, but there will be sports in between."

Offering her verdict on White's remarks, Yamauchi stressed that any sport where sex is affected "should have separate categories".

Yamauchi argued: "If a sport is sex affected, even to the tiniest degree, then there must be a separate male category. We've seen males deliberately underperforming in the female category - this makes a total mockery of sports.

"Sport is about doing your absolute best and male sandbagging to try and hide their male advantage, is just totally corrupting what sport is."

When pressed by Patrick on why women of the Labour Party "struggle to stand up for women", White responded: "Labour stands up for everyone, that's the point of the Equality Act. It balances the needs of all people, and where it's fair to exclude, it allows exclusion.

"And where it's not fair to exclude, it doesn't permit exclusion.'

News
World News
UK News
Devon News

Weather
World Weather
UK Weather
Devon Weather

Business
Directory
UK Jobs
Devon Jobs
Business Networking

News Network Logo

Travel
World Travel
UK Travel
Devon Travel
Hotels
Flights

Things To Do
Restaurants
Entertainment
Events
Offers

Contact
Directory Contact
Jobs Contact
Business Networking Contact
Adverts Contact

Copyright News Network © 2024 All Rights Reserved